My Photo

What I'm Reading Now or Recently Read

« Christian Movie Review or "How Come So Many Christian Movies Stink?" | Main | Afghanistan Deports Korean Christians »

Comments

Jen

Thank you for posting this. I have always wonder what the difference was. I have a persian friend but was always too afraid to ask because I didn't want to offend him. The media is always talking about the sunnis and the shites but all manages to neglect to tell why there against eachother. As, I was reading this though I truthfully wondered if there was a right side to agree with. Do you personally have a side that you side with? Thanks again for posting this God bless you!
~Jen~

janet

Thanks for educating me on this, and no, the sword-head-hitting thing doesn't sound like much fun. Do you suppose they pass around Tylenol during these shin-digs?

Keya

Thanks very much for posting this imformation it is really helping me with my summer reading project that I have to finish in a couple of day it gave me a straight forward answer and its like you knew i was going to be needing this information it really helped.THANK YOU AGAIN

you can all go to hell

Mike

This kind of informational article is a great idea. A few points of clarification:

Iraq is in fact predominantly Shi'ite, just like Iran is. The war between the two could still be framed as taking part in the context of the religious conflict, though, since Saddam himself was from the Iraqi Sunni minority, and used his power to make this population much more wealthy and influential within his Ba'athist Party. After the Iranian Revolution in 1979 led to a Shi'ite theocracy being established across his eastern border, Saddam was worried this could incite rebellion among his own Shi'ite minority, toppling his regime from power. This caused the conflict. (A more obvious difference between the two nations is ethnic, not religious: Iraq is an Arab nation while Iranians are considered Persian)

Abu Bakr did eventually become a "father-in-law" to Mohammed, but first he was simply a close friend and neighbor. Abu Bakr was one of the first to accept Islam, and did much to spread the word to others living in the area. It was after all this that he married his daughter to Mohammed.

Ali was not only Mohammed's cousin, but also his son-in-law, marrying Mohammed's daughter Fatimah. And so, the Shi'ite's position not only relies on Mohammed's reported expressed will, as you correctly identified, but also (albeit less so) on a family inheritance basis.

You picked especially bloody pictures to illustrate Ashura, the day on which many Shi'ites commemorate the martyrdom of Mohammed's grandson, Husayn Ibn Ali. The practice of head-cutting is an extension of the practice of "chest beating" that some Mulsim men take part in on this day(self-flagellation wasn't only used by Catholics, though this is usually relatively minor in comparison), and is fairly uncommon and plenty controversial amongst the Muslim community, and has been outright banned by multiple religious authorities. Parents involving their children is also extremely rare. Most Shi'ites spend the day participating in much more standard forms of remembrance, including the recitation of poems and stories concerning Husayn, ceremonial community meals at the Mosque, and even passion plays.

Not all Muslims hate Israel. Not all Muslims hate the United States. Not all Muslims are committed to putting the world under the jurisdiction of Islamic law, and certainly it's only an extremely tiny minority who is in favor of doing this by violent means. However, it is true that Shi'ites and Sunnis are more or less equally likely or unlikely to hold such positions.

Ahmed

Thanks for the great article and thanks mike for a nice comment. However, I am a Sunni and have some extra infos on this subject...
1. Abu Bakr did not elect him self after Muhammed's death. He voted for Umar ib AlKhattab and Abu Obayda.
2. Ali ib Abi Taleb voted for Abu Bakr to be the successor of Muhammed (PBUH).
3. Shittes says that when you kill a Sunni you will get rewarded by God !!
4. Shittes bellive that Ahlulbait (Muhammed, Ali, Fatimah and their sons and grandsons) have some kind of superpowers. eg.: knowing the future, controlling the weather, flying, bringing dead people to life ... etc. While we "Sunnis" bellive that they are normal people just like you and me.
5. Shittes bellive that most of "Alsahaba" who are Muhammed's friends, are liars and killers of Ahlulbait and they only wanted to be the successors of Muhammed for the power. That's why they hate most of Alsahaba. Sunnis on the other hand, bellive that they were close and there was a good relationship between them. eg.: most of Alsahaba were married from Ahlulbait. Plus, Ali named 3 of his children after 3 of Muhammed's best friends "Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman".
6. We don't hate the USA as we have lots of American friends. However, maybe some of the old people hates them.

I hope that I was helpful...

The comments to this entry are closed.

Disclaimer

  • These are some of my personal (and in process) views, opinions, musings and questions. They reflect my journey and not my conclusions. They do not in any way reflect the direction, feelings, beliefs or expressions of the church I pastor or the people that attend.