Apes: In the Image of God?
Domestic Violence and the Evangelical Church

Where Was God in the Amish Killings?" Trouble in Paradise

AmishwomenIt's ironic that the killings of the young Amish children were in the village of Paradise, Pennsylvania. It was the third school violence incident in the United States involving guns in one week.  This time it was in the most unlikely of places, in an Amish community, where non-violence and pacifism are practiced and held as high vlaues.

Where was God in the midst of the killing of the Amish school children? It's a good question and one that we should ask and try to answer. When we start to dig a little deeper, looking at the lives of some of those involved, we start to see Him all over the place. Understanding where God was begins with the knowledge that faith goes deeper than tragedy and life goes deeper than death.

THE AMISH COMMUNITY DOESN'T SEE GOD AS REMOVED FROM THE SITUATION.  In fact their lifestyle and belief structure predicts that such horrible things will happen. The Intelligencer Journal, a Lancaster County newspaper, quotes Amish researcher Donald Kimball, "The Amish are a resilient, peace-loving people of faith who won't be changed by Monday's spasm of violence, which they likely will view as a one-time incident. 'I think the community will understand it as an aberration, a crime committed by a man with a severe psychiatric disorder... I think they have a sense of resignation in accepting these kinds of things as somehow a part of God's larger plan.'"  David Weaver-Zercher, of Messiah College said in the same article that the Amish have a view of the world as "an evil place, and one's only security is with God."

THE ELDERS IN THE AMISH COMMUNITY ARE TALKING FORGIVENESS.  Rev. Robert Schenck told CNN he was standing with the grandfather of one of the slain girls, while the grandfather was teaching the young boys that they were not to hate. He is quoted as saying, "We must not think evil of this man." 

Amish woodworker, Sam Stoltzfus told an Associated Press reporter that "the families would be sustained by their faith." He said, "We think it was God's plan, and we're going to have to pick up the pieces and keep going. A funeral to us is a much more important thing than the day of birth because we believe in the hereafter."

The same article that quotes Stoltzfus, quotes Jack Meyer, a member of the Brethren community who said people were trying to follow the teachings of Jesus. He said, "I don't think there's anybody here that wants to do anything but forgive and not only reach out to those who have suffered a loss in that way but to reach out to the family of the man who committed these acts."  Wow! Reaching out to the family of the man that killed your children. Supernatural power and love exists in the hearts of the effected Amish families. God is spilling out all over that situation.

THE KILLER WAS HAVING AN AWFUL TIME IN HIS RELATIONSHIP WITH GOD. Charles Carl Roberts IV, was having a hard time finding God in just about anything. He was experiencing a number of troubling thoughts that he recorded in suicide notes he left for his family. He was particularly troubled by the death of his daughter, Elise, born prematurely in 1997 and living for only 20 minutes. In his note Robarts said Elise's death, "changed my life forever. I haven't been the same since it affected me in a way I never felt possible. I am filled with so much hate, hate towards myself, hate towards God and unimaginable emptiness it seems like every time we do something fun I think about how Elise wasn't here to share it with us and I go right back to anger." Whew, that's some tough stuff, really rough emotions. But not a denial of God or His existence, just an overall anger.

One of the strangest places that God showed up in the incident was that Marie Roberts, the killer's wife was leading a prayer meeting for the community's schoolchildren at the time that he had stormed into the one-room classroom.  Marie Roberts has been asking for prayer all along in this tragedy. CNN reported on Wednesday night, October 4th in an interview with two of the midwives that delivered two of the Amish girls that died, that Marie Roberts had asked to meet with the families of the slain children after the funeral and the Amish bishop agreed.

Even emergency response workers were saying "God was with us while we were taking care of those kids."

SPONTANEOUS PRAYER MEETINGS ERUPTED ACROSS LANCASTER COUNTY.  Lancaster Online reported on one of the many meetings. “We come here tonight as a grieving community,” Sam Smucker, pastor of The Worship Center, said. “We’ve come here to pray and proclaim the lordship of Christ and to put our arms around each other and the community and ask God to put his arms around us. God hears our prayers.”

Contemporary Christian artist Michael W. Smith led the group in worship, playing the piano and singing hymns like “It Is Well With My Soul,” as well as praise songs
like “Above All.”

Smith, who originally had been scheduled to perform at a rally for U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum in Lancaster Tuesday night, said, “It’s not an accident that I’m here (at The Worship Center’s prayer vigil). I’m a big believer in the providence of God.”

Smith told those attending the vigil that the shooting “could be your grandest
opportunity to turn tragedy into good, to grieve with those who grieve. What happened (Monday) will see what you’re made of.” As long as it takes to heal, “we have to stand in the gap.”

Of all the places in the world, Smith said, this is the last place one would think anything like this would happen. “But God is in control. ... Was this God’s will? Absolutely not. But he will use it for good,” Smith said. “Satan has won the battle
— temporarily. God has overcome the evil one. Let’s get on with building the kingdom. Let’s get on with God’s agenda.”

Smith closed his portion of the service by dedicating his new song, “See You on the Other Side” to the “five precious girls” who died in the shooting, Naomi Rose Ebersol, Anna Mae Stoltzfus, Marian Fisher, Mary Liz Miller and Lina Miller.

THE POWER OF GOD WAS EVIDENT IN SO MANY PLACES IN THE MIDST OF SUCH A HORRIBLE TRAGEDY. Forgiveness is being extended to Roberts family by the Amish. God has been evident throughout this whole situation.  Enos Miller, the grandfather of the two Miller sisters, was with both of the girls when they died. He was out walking near the schoolhouse before dawn Wednesday _ he said he couldn't sleep _ when he was asked by a reporter for WGAL-TV whether he had forgiven the gunman.

"In my heart, yes," he said, explaining it was "through God's help."



Joe, thanks for not being afraid to talk about hard stuff. All I can do if weep and pray for those people. As I watched the coverage on the news I prayed, "Come quickly Lord Jesus." But yes, I know He is working.


Joe, thanks for covering this from a Christian perspective, as I would expect of the Amish people. I know God is with them, as HE is with all of us despite the world and all its pain. I can't help wondering if the fact the killer lost his own child may have twisted his mind somehow to take little girls belonging to other parents. Satan is so easily involved in any highly emotional situation. I pray for the killer and his family, too. How sick he was in his heart and mind. I too pray that God continue to give strength to the Amish and grace of forgiveness to any who carry hatred or anger in their hearts. God bless. D

Jeff Eilenberger

There is a lot to be said for tight knit communities to reinforce what He says about situations such as these. In todays world it is very easy to get caught up in what the world says about vengence rather than what His Word says. So let's continue to build each other up in His Word and help one another to walk against the tide of the world, and if something like this should happen to us; let us be a true witness of His Grace to the world. Peace, Jeff

Linda Dinerstein

As the Body of Christ, may we minister to each other in these situations, grieving with those who grieve and comforting each other with the comfort God has given us in times of trouble. Crises like these really help me to put my own "storms of life" into proper perspective. This is a tough and heartbreaking world we live in. But God promises to get us through, and may we nonetheless not grow weary & continue to offer sacrifices of praise to our Almighty God in the storms we don't understand. Looks like the Amish are a great example of faith in our Creator.
As Casting Crowns writes,
"I was sure by now, God You would have reached down and wiped our tears away, stepped in and saved the day. But once again, I say amen and it's still raining; as the thunder rolls I barely hear You whisper through the rain, 'I'm with you'; and as Your mercy falls I raise my hands and praise the God Who gives and takes away.
"And I'll praise you in this storm, and I will lift my hands, for You are who You are no matter where I am; and every tear I've cried You hold in your hand; You never left my side, and though my heart is torn, I will praise You in this storm." Grace & peace to all, Linda

Charles Wood

Great piece. So often in life, God allows us to go through very difficult circumstances or even terrible tragedies and we rarely have clear answers as to exactly why God would allow such things to happen. If you look at what comes out of many of these events, you see the hand of God bringing comfort and strength to those affected.

The world watches how we believers respond to terrorist attacks, school shootings, natural disasters and the list goes on and on in these amazing times. I know I am amazed by what God does through his flock when He allows these events to come into our lives. I think that many that don't yet have a relationship with Him are even more blown away when they see or hear the testimonies from those Christians affected or see those that respond to the tragedy in an amazing way.

As we now have cable and internet news that constantly transmit these poignant displays of what a difference God can make in someone's life, I take comfort in knowing that God is in complete control and that He can transform something that devastated lives into something that remarkably changes the lives of others in an eternal way. As Joseph said to his brothers, "You intended to harm me, but God intended it for good..." Gen.50:20. As lives were eventually saved (and the future nation of Israel)as a result of something that was meant for evil in Joseph's day, I think God is touching people's lives today in an awesome way in the midst of these events.

joe paskewich

Hey everyone great comments! Sounds like we've all had quite a bit of pain in our lives. I'm listening to a seminary class these days as I walk, and the professor quoted F.F. Bruce in his book on church history called "The Spreading Flame." Bruce is quoted as saying, "The church was created for catastrophe." Paul said we "comfort with the comfort we've received." I think in the near future we're going to have lots of opportunites to shine like lights in the darkness. Strap yourself in, it's going to be a wild ride!


I have not taken the time to read your whole article (and not sure I will have time) but by the title I wanted to add a comment that I heard today on WCSE radio station. It was made by a man who lost his child in the Columbine school shootings in response to someone asking him, "Where was God in that?" He replied, "God was in the same place He was when His son Jesus was killed." I thought his perspective was incredible! Jesus died to make us a way to Heaven. Praise and Thanks to God who sees from the beginning to the end and all in between.

The comments to this entry are closed.